AIMultiple ResearchAIMultiple Research

5 Best Proxy Managers in 2024: In-Depth Analysis & Comparison

Updated on Jan 10
5 min read
Written by
Gulbahar Karatas
Gulbahar Karatas
Gulbahar Karatas
Gülbahar is an AIMultiple industry analyst focused on web data collection, applications of web data and application security.

She is a frequent user of the products that she researches. For example, she is part of AIMultiple's web data benchmark team that has been annually measuring the performance of top 9 web data infrastructure providers.

She previously worked as a marketer in U.S. Commercial Service.

Gülbahar has a Bachelor's degree in Business Administration and Management.
View Full Profile

Effectively managing  proxies is a crucial aspect of web scraping projects. However, websites may ban IP addresses or present CAPTCHAs if they detect suspicious activity from a proxy. Users must have efficient strategies to handle scraping challenges, such as using additional proxies. Using proxies poses its own challenges, especially when dealing with multiple proxies. Proxy managers simplify and optimize the management of multiple proxies by ensuring their performance and security. 

In this guide, we’ll explore the must-have features of proxy managers and the top solutions available in the market. By weighing the pros and cons of each proxy management tool, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs and requirements.

What is a proxy?

A proxy server acts as a gateway between a user’s device (client) and the internet (server) (Figure 1). The proxy receives the connection request from clients and forwards it to the target website to conceal the clients’ IP addresses.

Figure 1: Diagram illustrating the proxy workflow

The diagram illustrating the proxy workflow, in which a user's request is routed through the proxy server, which then retrieves the requested content from the target website and returns it to the user while concealing the user's IP address.
Source: The Ultimate Guide to Proxy Server Types

What is a proxy manager?

A proxy manager is a software that manages multiple proxy servers in one place and automates the process of routing traffic through these servers.

Evaluating Proxy Managers: Tips for making the right choice

  1. Performance: When selecting a proxy manager, it is critical to ensure that the solution can handle your specific data collection needs. For example, a good proxy manager should:
    • Provide fast connections to minimize delays between requests
    • Handle a large number of concurrent connections
    • Enable distribute network traffic to avoid server overloads
  2. Security and anonymity: It is critical to ensure that the proxy manager you use can secure data transmission between your device and the target web server. Ensure the proxy manager supports encryption protocols, such as SSL/TLS.
  3. User-Friendly interface: Your proxy manager should provide an overview of essential proxy metrics, such as connection status and data usage. A user-friendly dashboard allows users to monitor and manage their proxy usage easily. If a free trial is available, you can use it to determine whether the proxy manager’s interface meets your specific requirements.
  4. Integration capabilities: It is essential that the proxy manager you select integrates seamlessly with your existing software, tools, or applications. Check the vendor’s website to see which devices  or platforms their products are compatible with.

For example, if you intend to use a proxy manager in your data collection tasks, ensure that your selected proxy manager is compatible with your web scraping tool.

  1. Pricing: Pricing is another factor to consider when selecting a proxy manager. Here are some price-related considerations for making an informed decision:
  • Assess the overall value offered by the vendor to determine whether the features are worth the cost
  • Evaluate the various pricing models
  • Check to see if there is customizable plan is available
  • Customizable plans enable you to choose the most appropriate package based on your needs and budget
  • Be aware of any hidden fees or additional costs.

Top 5 Proxy Managers: Which tool is right for you?

1. Bright Data

Bright Data’s Proxy Manager helps developers simplify the management of proxies while enhancing their performance and anonymity.

Source: Bright Data

Key features

  • IP rotation: The proxy manager rotates IP addresses automatically to reduce the likelihood of being blocked or detected by websites
  • Geo-targeting: Bright Data’s Proxy Manager enables users to select and use proxies based on specific cities and regions.
  • Performance monitoring: The proxy manager provides real-time monitoring and analytics features, such as connection speeds and uptime. You can monitor all the web requests made through a proxy with detailed request logs.
  • Load balancing: You can distribute network traffic evenly across available proxies to avoid any single server becoming a bottleneck.
  • API access: Bright Data Proxy Manager API allows users to integrate the proxy manager with custom applications.
  • User-friendly interface: Bright Data’s Proxy Manager has an easy-to-use interface that simplifies proxy management and monitoring without requiring extensive technical knowledge.
  • Easy installation: The straightforward installation of the proxy manager reduces the risk of technical issues and misconfigurations. Individuals with limited or no technical knowledge can easily install the proxy manager (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Demonstrating the installation process of Bright Data’s Proxy Manager

Image provides installation instructions for Bright Data's Proxy Manager.
Source: Bright Data

Cons of Bright Data Proxy Manager

  • Pricing: While Bright Data’s Proxy Manager offers a range of features, the pricing may be relatively expensive compared to some competitors. This can be a concern for users with a limited budget.

2. Oxylabs

Oxy Proxy Manager app is a free app that allows you to manage proxies on your mobile device. A Chrome browser extension is also available if you prefer not to use an app for proxy management. Oxy Proxy Manager allows you to configure and switch between multiple proxy servers.

Key features

  • Oxy Proxy Manager App works with any proxy provider of your choice.
  • There are no hidden fees or additional costs associated with using the app.
  • The proxy manager allows users to add an unlimited number of proxy servers.

Cons Oxy Proxy Manager

  • Mobile proxy managers might not use the proxy settings at the system level or might have their proxy configuration.

3. Nginx

Nginx Proxy Manager enables users to manage connections between clients and backend servers. It is important to note that Nginx Proxy Manager is intended  to manage connections between clients and backend servers rather than all your proxies, as Bright Data’s Proxy Manager is.

Key features

  • SSL/TLS termination: Nginx Proxy Manager can be configured to handle SSL/TLS encryption and decryption.
  • Basic HTTP authentication: Nginx Proxy Manager supports HTTP/2, allowing faster communication between clients and servers.
  • Reverse proxy support: The proxy manager forwards client connection requests to backend servers while masking the clients’ real IP addresses.
  • Security: Nginx Proxy Manager offers a range of security features that help protect your servers from common web-based attacks. These security measures include:
    • Access control: Allows users to set up access controls based on IP addresses, enabling them to protect sensitive data from unauthorized access (Figure 3).

Figure 3:  Nginx Proxy Manager’s access control functionality

The user interface of Nginx Proxy Manager displays access control functionality, including options to add, modify, and delete IP address-based restrictions.
Source: Nginx Proxy Manager1
  • Authentication: You can configure Nginx Proxy Manager to require authentication for specific locations using different authentication methods, such as HTTP authentication.
  • Protection against SQL Injection
  • Protection against XSS (Cross-Site Scripting) attacks

Cons of Nginx Proxy Manager

  • Limited functionality: Nginx Proxy Manager’s functionality is limited to reverse proxy and SSL/TLS management. It might not be the most efficient way to manage  a pool of proxy servers.

4. IPRoyal

IPRoyal Proxy Manager is a free Google Chrome and Firefox extension that allows users to manage and switch between multiple proxies directly from their browsers.

Key features

  • Proxy profiles: IPRoyal Chrome Proxy Manager allows users to create and manage multiple proxy profiles, including the IP address, port, and protocol. You can use your single-proxy profile for all browser traffic.
  • Proxy protocols support: It supports various proxy protocols such as HTTP, HTTPS, and FTP.
  • Quick switch: The proxy manager allows you to switch between multiple proxy servers with a single click.
  • Geo-targeting: The extension includes geo-targeting features, enabling users  to select proxy servers based on their geo-location.

Cons IPRoyal Proxy Manager

  • Limited scope: Proxy management browser extensions offer proxy settings management within the browser because they are not a system-wide solution for proxy management.

5. Zyte

Zyte Smart Proxy Manager is a proxy management tool for web scraping and data extraction tasks.

Key features

Figure 4: Demonstrates the use of Smart Proxy Manager with the Python Requests

The image shows how to use Smart Proxy Manager with Python requests.
Source: Zyte2
  • Residential IPs: The proxy manager supports residential IP addresses.
  • SLA and support: Offers service level agreements (SLAs) and dedicated support, enhancing the web scraping experience and providing a robust proxy management solution.

Cons of Zyte Smart Proxy Manager

  • Cost: its pricing can be relatively high, especially for those with limited budgets or small-scale projects.
  • Limited use case: The proxy manager is designed specifically for data extraction. It may not be the most suitable option for other proxy management use cases outside of web scraping, such as load balancing and caching.

Transparency statement:

AIMultiple serves numerous emerging tech companies, including Bright Data.

More on proxies

For guidance to choose the right tool, go through data-driven list of proxy services, and reach out to us:

Find the Right Vendors
Gulbahar Karatas
Gülbahar is an AIMultiple industry analyst focused on web data collection, applications of web data and application security. She is a frequent user of the products that she researches. For example, she is part of AIMultiple's web data benchmark team that has been annually measuring the performance of top 9 web data infrastructure providers. She previously worked as a marketer in U.S. Commercial Service. Gülbahar has a Bachelor's degree in Business Administration and Management.

Next to Read

Comments

Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.

0 Comments