Chatbots have been around since the 1960s and went commercial in the late 2000s, but they never caught on like ChatGPT did. That sudden popularity created confusion – many businesses now think “chatbot” automatically means “ChatGPT-style AI.”
It doesn’t. ChatGPT is one specific type of chatbot, and it’s not the right fit for every business process.
If you’re considering text-based conversational AI for your business, you need to understand what separates traditional chatbots from generative AI like ChatGPT. The differences affect cost, complexity, reliability, and whether the tool will actually solve your problem.
We’ll break down how each type works, what they’re good at, what they can’t do, and how to choose between them based on your actual needs – not hype.
How do you pick between a traditional AI chatbot and a generative chatbot?
Best For | Traditional Chatbots | Generative AI Chatbot |
|---|---|---|
Simple, repetitive tasks | ✅ | |
Creative, human-like conversations | ✅ | |
Structured, rule-based interactions | ✅ | |
Budget-friendly and easy to maintain | ✅ | |
Context-aware, dynamic responses | ✅ | |
Advanced infrastructure and customization | ✅ |
You should pick a traditional AI Chatbot if you:
- Need to handle repetitive, predictable queries: FAQs, appointment scheduling, order tracking, password resets – these don’t require creativity or nuance.
- Require consistent, scripted responses: Compliance-heavy industries need exact wording. You can’t risk AI improvising on legal disclosures or medical advice.
- Have a limited budget: Rule-based and AI chatbots cost significantly less than generative AI, both in licensing and operational costs.
- Run on limited infrastructure: Your systems can’t handle the computational load of running or connecting to large language models.
- Want complete control over interactions: You need to know exactly what the chatbot will say in every scenario. Unpredictability is unacceptable.
You should pick a generative chatbot if you:
- Need unique, dynamic responses: Your customers ask varied, complex questions that can’t be templated. Each interaction requires customized answers.
- Value creative, human-like responses: You’re not just providing information – you want engaging, contextual conversations that feel natural.
- Have the infrastructure: You can handle API costs, integration complexity, and the computational requirements of generative AI.
- Can collect feedback and iterate: You have processes to monitor conversations, catch errors, and continuously improve the system.
There are currently three types of chatbots:
1. Rule-based chatbots
These are the simplest type. They match what you type to a set of predefined responses – basically a flowchart turned into a conversation.
How they work: Type “I want to return an item,” and the chatbot searches its database for that phrase or similar keywords. Find a match? You get the return policy. No match? It either asks you to rephrase or connects you to a human.
What they’re good at:
- Giving the exact same answer every time (crucial for compliance)
- Handling predictable, repetitive questions
- Low cost and simple setup
Where they fail:
- Can’t understand variations in phrasing
- Never learn or improve on their own
- Frustrate users when questions don’t match expected patterns
2. AI-Powered Chatbots
These use machine learning to understand user intent. They’re trained on specific topics or industries.
How they work: Instead of matching keywords, they analyze the intent behind messages. They understand that “I want to return this,” “How do I send this back?” and “Can I get a refund?” all mean the same thing. They pick the best response from their training data.
What they’re good at:
- Understanding different ways of asking the same question
- Getting better as more people use them
- Deep knowledge in their specific domain
- Reasonable costs ($500-3,000/month)
Where they struggle:
- Can’t answer questions outside their trained topic
- Need retraining every few months to stay current
- Responses come from templates, not generated fresh each time
3. Generative chatbots
Generative chatbots use vast amounts of data to answer questions across almost any topic. ChatGPT falls into this category. They’re less specialized in any one area but can handle a much broader range of conversations.
What they’re good at:
- Handling questions on virtually any topic
- Creating nuanced, contextual responses on the fly
- Working with both text and images
- Learning from each conversation
- Reasoning across different subjects
Where they struggle:
- Higher costs ($1,000-10,000+ per month depending on usage)
- Sometimes make up information that sounds right but isn’t (hallucinations)
- Need constant monitoring to catch errors
- Responses can be inconsistent
How Smart Are They Really?
One big difference is how well each type can reason through problems.
Level 1: Pattern Matching (Rule-Based)
These just recognize keywords. Type “refund” and you get the refund policy. But say “I want my money back” and they might not understand because those exact words aren’t in their database.
Real-world impact: About 40% of customer queries don’t match the expected phrasing, leading to failed interactions.
Level 2: Understanding Intent (AI Chatbots)
These understand that “refund,” “money back,” and “return payment” all mean the same thing. But they can’t combine multiple ideas or reason across different topics.
Real-world impact: Success rate jumps to 70-80% because the bot understands intent, not just exact phrases.
Level 3: Following Context (Basic Generative AI)
These remember what you talked about earlier. Ask “What’s your return policy?” then “How long does the refund take?” and it knows you’re still talking about returns.
Real-world impact: Conversations feel natural because the bot tracks context across multiple messages.
Level 4: Multi-Step Thinking (Advanced Generative AI)
These can chain information together logically.
Example: “I bought item X three months ago. Your policy says 90 days. Can I still return it?”
The chatbot calculates the timeline, checks the policy, and gives you an answer based on reasoning through multiple pieces of information.
Level 5: Connecting Different Topics (Frontier Generative AI)
These pull information from entirely different areas and synthesize it.
Example: “Compare your product to a competitor, considering industry trends and my previous purchases.”
It combines product data, market analysis, and your purchase history to provide a comprehensive comparison.
What Works Best for Different Industries
E-Commerce
About 70% of e-commerce queries are transactional like order status and returns. Rule-based chatbots handle these perfectly. The other 30% are product questions where AI adds real value. Most e-commerce companies see a return on investment in 6-12 months.
SaaS and Tech Support
Technical questions have lots of variations but stay within your product’s scope. An AI chatbot trained on your product can reduce support tickets by 40-60%. Typical ROI happens in 8-14 months.
Healthcare
Healthcare has strict regulations. You need auditable, consistent responses. You cannot afford the chatbot making up medical information. Most healthcare organizations see ROI in 12-18 months.
Financial Services
Financial queries are complex but must stay within regulatory boundaries. This requires extensive testing and oversight. Typical ROI takes 14-20 months.
Content and Media
Your audience asks diverse, creative questions and expects sophisticated answers. Generative AI fits naturally here. ROI usually comes in 10-16 months.
Available Platforms
Rule-Based Options
Tidio, Chatbot.com, ManyChat: $50-200 per month Good for small businesses and basic automation.
AI-Powered Options
Zendesk, Intercom, Drift: $500-2,000 per month
Ada, Ultimate.ai: $2,000-5,000 per month Good for mid-sized companies with defined support categories.
Generative AI Options
OpenAI API (GPT-4): $0.03-0.12 per 1,000 tokens (cost varies by usage)
Anthropic Claude: $0.015-0.075 per 1,000 tokens
Custom Enterprise Solutions: $5,000-50,000 per month Good for large companies and complex use cases.
Hybrid Solutions
Kore.ai, Yellow.ai: $3,000-10,000 per month
Custom Integration: Varies Good for organizations optimizing cost and performance.
How does a chatbot work?
Chatbots are programs designed to engage with humans through human-like interactions. They adhere to the following steps while doing this:
- Receiving user input: This is a text or voice-based message or command from the user.
- Processing input:
- Tokenization: The Input is tokenized into individual words. For example, “How are you?” is tokenized into “How,” “are”, “you”, “?”.
- Intent understanding: The chatbot tries to understand the user’s intent using natural language processing (NLP) and natural language understanding (NLU). They decide if the query is a question, command, or sentiment.
- Entity recognition: The entity or keywords in the input are identified. For example, in “Book a ticket to Paris”, “Paris” is an entity representing a destination.
- Determining the response: The chatbot generates appropriate responses based on their type. In the next sections, we will focus solely on generative chatbots. For more comprehensive information, refer to the article on chatbot types.
- Returning the response: The best-matched response is finally returned to the user.
What are the differences between traditional chatbots and ChatGPT?
AI-based and generative chatbots like ChatGPT are conversational agents that automate user interactions. However, there are differences among them.
Architecture and design
- AI chatbots: Leverage ML models to create responses based on the specific data they’re trained with.
- ChatGPT: An advanced language model, built on the Transformer, that generates new responses based on patterns learnt from vast amounts of data.
Flexibility
- AI chatbots are moderately flexible. They can create different kinds of the same answer, but can’t expand beyond their training data.
- ChatGPT can generate responses to many questions since they don’t rely on pre-defined templates.
Training
- AI chatbots are trained on specialized datasets tailored to specific applications or domains. They may require fine-tuning or additional data. They will likely not answer questions outside of their domain. AI chatbots offer depth determined by the training data and their ML algorithms.
- For instance, if trained on data about dogs, they could answer dog-related questions. However, if you asked it to name a different mammal besides dogs, it would likely not respond because the only type of mammal it knows is dogs.
- ChatGPT is trained on more diverse datasets than other AI chatbots, which enables it to possess knowledge across a wide range of topics and generalize original data. This capability is arguably its most considerable appeal to users. ChatGPT offers greater depth than typical AI chatbots and can connect various topics effectively.
Figure 1: ChatGPT connecting laptops to books.
Multimodality
AI chatbots: Generally text-only. Advanced ones might handle images, but multimodality isn’t standard.
ChatGPT: Can process and generate responses from both text and images. You can upload a photo and ask questions about it, request captions, generate code based on a screenshot, or create alt text for accessibility.
Personalization
AI chatbots: Can personalize within their domain.
Example: A music chatbot trained on genre data can recommend songs based on your stated preferences for rock or jazz.
ChatGPT: Personalizes across domains.
Figure 2: ChatGPT making cross-references between different categories.
Reasoning
Reasoning models can be categorized by complexity and ability to handle context and abstraction.
Level 0: No reasoning (Rule-based chatbots)
Purely reactive. Responds to predefined keywords with static answers.
Level 1: Direct, linear reasoning (Basic AI chatbots)
Single-step logic. Can answer “What’s your refund policy?” but struggles with conditional questions.
ChatGPT capability: Uses Level 1 but extends far beyond it.
Level 2: Limited multi-condition reasoning
Handles slightly expanded context.
Example: “If my order is delayed, can I request a refund?”
Some advanced AI chatbots reach this level. ChatGPT easily handles it and goes further.
Level 3: Multi-step reasoning
Connects information across conditions.
Example: “I ordered three items. One arrived damaged, one is delayed, and one is perfect. What are my options for each?”
Most traditional chatbots can’t handle this – it requires tracking multiple conditions and applying different logic to each. ChatGPT operates comfortably at this level.
Level 4: Multi-dimensional reasoning
Synthesizes diverse inputs across different domains.
Example: “Compare renewable energy policies in the U.S. and Germany and explain their impact on global carbon emissions.”
This requires knowledge of policy, geography, environmental science, and international economics. Traditional chatbots can’t do this. ChatGPT handles it by pulling from multiple knowledge areas.
Level 5+: Meta-reasoning
Systems evaluate their own reasoning process or explore alternative solutions.
Example: ChatGPT might respond: “I’m moderately confident in this answer, but there are several ways to interpret your question. Could you clarify whether you mean X or Y?”
FAQs
Further reading
Cem's work has been cited by leading global publications including Business Insider, Forbes, Washington Post, global firms like Deloitte, HPE and NGOs like World Economic Forum and supranational organizations like European Commission. You can see more reputable companies and resources that referenced AIMultiple.
Throughout his career, Cem served as a tech consultant, tech buyer and tech entrepreneur. He advised enterprises on their technology decisions at McKinsey & Company and Altman Solon for more than a decade. He also published a McKinsey report on digitalization.
He led technology strategy and procurement of a telco while reporting to the CEO. He has also led commercial growth of deep tech company Hypatos that reached a 7 digit annual recurring revenue and a 9 digit valuation from 0 within 2 years. Cem's work in Hypatos was covered by leading technology publications like TechCrunch and Business Insider.
Cem regularly speaks at international technology conferences. He graduated from Bogazici University as a computer engineer and holds an MBA from Columbia Business School.
Be the first to comment
Your email address will not be published. All fields are required.